
The Surgeon General鈥檚 report is one of many that spreads the narrative that teen mental health is in decline because of social media. While I won鈥檛 sit here and argue that there are no downsides to social media, it is important to understand that this narrative relies on studies that are short-term and correlational, and that a lot of literature either brushes over or completely ignores the benefits of social media for teens.
The United States is in the midst of a teen mental health crisis, with the CDC reporting that in 2021, . Many researchers have looked to social media as the main cause of this crisis, since social media is the most significant change in the way that teens have socialized over the past few decades. The data seems to point to a link between social media use and mental health issues, as the Surgeon General suggested.
However, it鈥檚 hard to tell whether increased social media use causes mental health issues, or the other way around. A that looked at the association between social media use and depression revealed that twice as many studies found nonsignificant associations than found positive associations. This means that while higher social media use is correlated with worse mental health, using more social media doesn鈥檛 necessarily cause depression. Since many teens use social media as a coping mechanism and to find communities they can relate to, teens with depression, anxiety, or other mental health issues might use social media more or differently than their neurotypical peers.
As someone with anxiety, my screen time shoots up when my anxiety levels rise. This isn鈥檛 because using my phone makes me more anxious, but because scrolling through Instagram Reels helps me decompress. So, despite the narrative spread by the Surgeon General and others, the evidence doesn鈥檛 show that social media use strongly impacts teen mental health.
Social media also provides a space for teens to connect with friends and explore their identities. Teens are growing up without free and available 鈥攁reas away from home or school鈥攚here they can socialize with peers. Instead of hanging out in malls or at skate parks, teens spend time with each other on Snapchat or Instagram. These social media sites serve the same function as in-person interactions. According to the American Academy of Pediatrics, to connect with their peers, explore their identities, and indulge in curiosities.
As a teenager, my friends and I stayed in touch after school by sending each other memes over Instagram direct messages. We made fan accounts for TV shows, books, and movies and built skills in writing, photo and video editing, and social media management through creating and sharing fan content.
LGBTQ+ youth also tend to spend a lot of time exploring their identities in online spaces. According to Senior Research Scientist Linda Chamaraman, Ph.D., of WCW鈥檚 Youth, Media and Wellbeing Research Lab, more anonymous sites such as Tumblr and learn more about their identities. For queer youth in homophobic areas, these spaces can serve as a lifeline, fostering social connections and creating a sense of community for people who might not otherwise have one. [The Youth, Media & Wellbeing Research Lab recently published a study about and the effect on their loneliness.]
Yes, this socializing doesn鈥檛 look much like it did 20 or 30 years ago, but different doesn鈥檛 always mean worse. Relationships formed between teens through social media are just as meaningful, even if they鈥檙e not happening face to face.
In the face of scholarly research that blames social media as the root cause for teen mental health issues, it鈥檚 important to remember that social media use isn鈥檛 inherently good or bad. Social media is designed to be addictive and more research needs to be done on long-term effects of use. But that doesn鈥檛 mean that we have to fear social media, or that we should overlook its positive effects. Next time you use social media, think about how it makes you feel, about the friends that you get to stay in contact with or the interests you get to pursue. Social media has changed the way we interact, but that鈥檚 not necessarily a bad thing.
Paige Sangston is a member of the 妻友社区 College Class of 2024 majoring in American Studies.